True Scary Stories: 10 Real Cases and What Investigators Found

True Scary Stories From Haunted Houses

Three of the most famous hauntings on record, and why each is still argued about.

The Enfield poltergeist (London, 1977–1979) In a council house on Green Street in Enfield, a family reported furniture moving, knocking in the walls and a gruff voice that seemed to come from 11-year-old Janet Hodgson. Investigators Maurice Grosse and Guy Lyon Playfair of the Society for Psychical Research believed the haunting was genuine. Other members were unconvinced, and skeptics pointed to evidence that the girls had faked some of the events. Nearly fifty years on, it is still one of the most argued-about true scary stories in Britain. ↳ Enfield poltergeist

Borley Rectory, “the most haunted house in England” Built in 1862 in Essex, Borley Rectory became famous through the psychic researcher Harry Price, who called it the most haunted house in England: footsteps, ringing bells, writing on the walls and a phantom nun. Then the twist. In 1956, three members of the Society for Psychical Research published a study concluding that Price had fraudulently produced some of the phenomena himself. Some earlier residents said they had never noticed anything at all. ↳ Borley Rectory

The Amityville house (New York, 1975) George and Kathy Lutz moved into a house in Amityville where a family had been killed a year earlier. They left after 28 days, describing terrifying events that became a bestselling book and a film. But in 1979 William Weber, the lawyer for the man convicted of the earlier killings, wrote: “I know this book is a hoax. We created this horror story over many bottles of wine.” The Lutzes maintained their account. Lawsuits followed on both sides. ↳ The Amityville Horror

Hauntings That Turned Out to Be Hoaxes

Some of the most influential true scary stories were later confessed or debunked, which makes them stranger, not less.

The Fox sisters and the rapping ghost (Hydesville, 1848) In a farmhouse in Hydesville, New York, two young sisters, Kate and Margaret Fox, said a spirit answered their questions with knocks. Their séances made them famous and helped launch the Spiritualist movement. Forty years later, in 1888, Margaret publicly confessed that the raps were a hoax and demonstrated how they made the sounds by cracking their joints. She later took the confession back. ↳ Fox sisters

The Brown Lady of Raynham Hall (Norfolk, 1936) A photograph taken on the staircase of Raynham Hall and published in Country Life magazine in 1936 seemed to show a veiled ghost gliding down the stairs. It is one of the most famous ghost photos ever taken. Skeptics including the investigator Joe Nickell have argued that a close look shows signs of a double exposure. ↳ Brown Lady of Raynham Hall

Gef, the talking mongoose (Isle of Man, 1930s) A farming family on the Isle of Man said an invisible creature called Gef lived in their walls, talked, sang and stole food. Journalists and investigators visited. Nobody outside the family saw it clearly, and the case is now generally regarded as a hoax, but it remains one of the oddest true stories in the history of ghost hunting. ↳ Gef

Real Encounters Nobody Fully Explained

The Bell Witch (Tennessee, 1817–1821) According to accounts collected later, the family of farmer John Bell, near what is now Adams, Tennessee, was tormented for four years by a mostly invisible entity that knocked, spoke and pulled at the children. The story became one of America’s best-known hauntings. Much of what is told comes from accounts written decades later, so historians treat it as a legend built around a real family. ↳ Bell Witch

Mothman (Point Pleasant, West Virginia, 1966–1967) Starting in November 1966, people in Point Pleasant reported a large winged figure with glowing red eyes. Then, on December 15, 1967, the Silver Bridge collapsed and 46 people died. A legend grew connecting the sightings to the disaster. Researchers have suggested the witnesses saw out-of-migration sandhill cranes, herons or barred owls; no link to the bridge collapse has ever been shown. ↳ Mothman

The Winchester house (California, 1884–1906) After her husband and infant daughter died, the rifle heiress Sarah Winchester spent decades expanding a house in San Jose, with stairs that lead to ceilings and doors that open onto walls. Legend says she built nonstop to confuse the spirits of people killed by Winchester rifles. That explanation is a legend that grew around the house; the documented record is of a wealthy widow who kept building for decades. ↳ Winchester Mystery House

The Philip experiment (Toronto, 1972) Members of the Toronto Society for Psychical Research invented a ghost. They wrote a life story for a fictional man named Philip, then sat around a table trying to contact him. They reported knocks and a table that moved. The point of the experiment was to test whether a group could produce séance effects from a ghost they knew was imaginary. ↳ Philip experiment

How We Chose These True Scary Stories

We included only cases with a documented record: named people and places, contemporary reports, or investigations that were published. We left out anonymous internet stories and anything gory. Where investigators found fraud, or where accounts were written long after the events, the story says so. If you know a source we should add, or spot an error, tell us through the contact page.

Telling True Scary Stories Aloud

Each case takes about a minute to read aloud. Start with what witnesses reported, pause, then give the twist: the confession, the double exposure, the fraud finding. Listeners usually find the real explanation as unsettling as the ghost. For more true stories with a darker edge, read creepy facts that sound fake, weird history facts, the real haunted places you can visit, or the legends behind scary urban legends. Prefer fiction? Our spooky stories are original and gentle.

True Scary Stories — FAQ